Nutroot Files Complaint Against Giuliani For NYT Ad

by Stephan Tawney on September 25, 2007

Note: Not against MoveOn that even the NYT says shouldn’t have gotten the ad price. No, against Giuliani. You’ll recognize the nutroot’s name.

Lane Hudson, who in recent weeks has sought to carve out a niche as something of election law vigilante, alleges in a complaint filed Tuesday morning with the Federal Election Commission that the Giuliani campaign broke election laws by accepting a discounted ad rate from the New York Times…

And this weekend, the New York Times’ public editor admitted in his column that the ad violated the newspaper’s policies regarding rates — and possibly content as well.

That prompted MoveOn.org to announce it would pay the difference between the discounted rate it received and the full price.

The offer only emboldened foes of the paper and the liberal political group….

But Hudson said Giuliani’s campaign is the one that has some answering to do.

“There’s no difference in how MoveOn got their ad and how the Giuliani campaign got their ad,” Hudson told Politico, calling on the Giuliani campaign to pay the difference between the discounted and full rates.

That’s not going to happen, said Giuliani campaign spokeswoman Maria Comella, who said in a statement that her boss’ ad was consistent with the Times’ ad rates and policy prohibiting personal attack ads.

The Times charges one rate for customers seeking a guarantee their ads will run on a specific date, and a lower rate for customers whose ads run “standby,” meaning they can request a certain date, but aren’t promised it.

Giuliani’s ad “was placed at the standby rate with no commitment it would run on a specific date,” said Comella. The ad did run on the campaign’s desired date.

That’s doesn’t prove anything. Just like you pay a stand-by rate for a flight, you may get on the plane at your desired time or you may be forced to wait. Giuliani wasn’t guaranteed a date – MoveOn was. The NYT was under intense public pressure for giving the liberal group a huge break – not giving the same to Giuliani as they did to MoveOn, would’ve only gone on to more pressure on them. Hudson would like to turn this story about an event that even the newspaper says was a mistake, into a story about a Republican candidate that responded and kept his ad within the paper’s established guidelines.



Leave a Reply