Did Hillary Take A Shot At Southerners?

by Stephan Tawney on October 23, 2007

Not sure. It’s feasible, and I certainly wouldn’t put it past her, but can’t be positive. Allah points out that it wouldn’t really matter, because Bubba comes from Arkansas, so it wouldn’t stick on her. But nothing bad ever sticks on her, does it?

“I was shocked when I learned Iowa and Mississippi have never elected a woman governor, senator or member of Congress,” she said. “There has got to be something at work here…

“I think Iowa poses a special burden, or a special obstacle to me because when you look at the numbers, how can Iowa be ranked with Mississippi? That’s not what I see. That’s not the quality. That’s not the communitarianism, that’s not the openness I see in Iowa.”

Doesn’t that sound like she’s saying she expects Mississippi to be backward but not Iowa?

I asked Clinton campaign spokesman Phil Singer about this. His response: “Clearly, she was referring to the historical fact that a woman has never been elected Governor or to the House or Senate from those states.”

Uh…right.

Over at the original column, it goes on:

“I was shocked when I learned Iowa and Mississippi have never elected a woman governor, senator or member of Congress. There has got to be something at work here,” she said, theorizing it may be the risk-averse nature of a state built around agriculture.

Sounds to me like she’s saying that farmers are afraid of women in roles of authority. Came off that way to Allah, too. He writes:

The obvious climbdown here is to say that she wasn’t referring to southerners generally, just to Mississippians, although that merely limits the insult instead of erasing it. Given the decades-long knock on her as an elitist, that’s not an insult she can afford. So how exactly does she spin this? And exit question two: If this does gain traction in the media, how long will it be before we hear that mellifluous southern accent of hers again? Over/under is four days.

I’m not sure she’s going to spin it. Even if she is, you won’t hear it over and over again in the majority of media, no matter how ridiculous.



Leave a Reply