A Republican proposal to stimulate the economy through tax breaks failed to reach the cloture threshold by just 3 votes in a Democrat-controlled U.S. Senate this evening. Many Democrats — including some you would not expect — broke ranks with Barack Obama and Harry Reid to support the Republican-crafted bill.
Among those who sided with Republicans on the bill include:
- Michael Bennet of Colorado
- Al Franken of Minnesota
- Kay Hagen of North Carolina
- Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota
- Joe Manchin of West Virginia
- Claire McCaskill of Missouri
- Robert Menendez of New Jersey
- Ben Nelson of Nebraska
- Bill Nelson of Florida
- Jon Tester of Montana
Most of these senators still voted with the White House on the unfunded Stimulus 2.0 legislation, which relies on the same old failed tax-and-spend policies that have left is with 9% unemployment and a $1.65 trillion deficit.
But, and this is crucial, ten Senate Democrats broke with their own party and supported Republican legislation to stimulate the economy through tax breaks — a proven method to create jobs and get the country back on track.
We’re making progress. Keep up the good work. Keep pressuring members of Congress to oppose failed tax-and-spend policies and to support proven, free market solutions. It’s starting to have an impact.


by Scott Gibbons on October 21, 2011